Determining the precise number of YouTube channels exceeding one million subscribers presents a considerable challenge due to the platform’s dynamic nature and lack of publicly available, real-time tracking data. While YouTube provides subscriber counts, a comprehensive aggregate figure is not directly disclosed. Estimates are derived from third-party analytics firms and data scraping techniques, offering an approximation rather than an absolute count.
The significance of achieving this subscriber milestone lies in its representation of substantial audience reach and potential for monetization. Historically, reaching one million subscribers has been associated with increased brand visibility, advertising revenue, and opportunities for content creators to expand their influence. This benchmark often signifies a channel’s transition from hobbyist pursuit to a potentially sustainable business enterprise.
Consequently, understanding the factors influencing channel growth and the methodologies used to estimate the prevalence of channels surpassing this key threshold becomes crucial for both aspiring creators and those analyzing the evolving landscape of online video content.
1. Estimated aggregate number
The “estimated aggregate number” serves as a crucial, albeit approximated, gauge of the prevalence of YouTube channels that have achieved the one million subscriber benchmark. Since YouTube does not release a definitive, real-time count, this estimate relies on the aggregation of data from various third-party analytics platforms. These platforms employ proprietary algorithms and data-scraping techniques to monitor channel subscriber counts and extrapolate the total number reaching this significant threshold. The accuracy of the “estimated aggregate number” is therefore intrinsically tied to the comprehensiveness and reliability of the data sources and analytical methods used. Fluctuations in these estimates reflect both organic channel growth and adjustments in the methodologies employed by analytics firms. A higher aggregate indicates a greater proportion of channels attaining widespread popularity, signifying the democratization of content creation and audience engagement. Conversely, a stagnant or declining aggregate might suggest increased competition, evolving audience preferences, or shifts in platform algorithms impacting channel visibility.
For instance, Social Blade, one of the most prominent YouTube analytics platforms, provides estimated subscriber counts for millions of channels. By compiling and analyzing this data, one can arrive at an approximate figure for the total number of channels exceeding one million subscribers. However, it’s crucial to recognize the inherent limitations. Different analytics firms might use varying methodologies, leading to discrepancies in their estimates. Moreover, these estimates are typically updated periodically, meaning the real-time number could differ. Despite these challenges, the “estimated aggregate number” remains valuable for gaining a sense of the overall scale and trajectory of YouTube’s ecosystem. Its importance is underscored by its application in market research, trend analysis, and strategic planning for both individual content creators and media companies operating on the platform.
In summary, while the exact figure remains elusive, the “estimated aggregate number” is a critical proxy for understanding the scope and evolution of channels with substantial subscriber bases. Its value lies in providing a macro-level perspective on the YouTube landscape, highlighting growth trends, and informing strategic decisions. The inherent limitations of relying on third-party estimates necessitate careful interpretation and consideration of the methodologies employed in their calculation. Continued refinement of these estimation techniques and increased transparency from YouTube regarding channel metrics would further enhance the accuracy and utility of this critical metric.
2. Data collection methods
The task of determining the number of YouTube channels exceeding one million subscribers hinges critically on the methodologies employed for data collection. The absence of a direct, publicly available figure from YouTube necessitates reliance on third-party analytics platforms. These platforms utilize a variety of techniques to gather data, each with its own strengths and limitations, directly influencing the accuracy and reliability of any resultant estimate. The primary method involves web scraping, where automated bots systematically extract publicly available data from YouTube channel pages. This includes subscriber counts, video views, upload frequency, and other metadata. The scale and efficiency of these scraping operations are essential for capturing a comprehensive snapshot of the YouTube ecosystem. However, web scraping can be susceptible to changes in YouTube’s website structure or terms of service, potentially disrupting data collection efforts. Furthermore, not all channels are equally accessible or accurately represented through publicly available data, introducing potential biases. For example, smaller or less active channels might be overlooked, affecting the overall accuracy of the estimated total.
Another common method involves leveraging YouTube’s API (Application Programming Interface). While the API offers a more structured and reliable way to access channel data, it also has limitations. YouTube imposes rate limits and access restrictions on API usage, making it challenging to collect data on a massive scale. Moreover, the API may not provide all the information needed to accurately estimate the number of channels with one million subscribers, particularly if certain data points are not publicly exposed. In addition to these automated methods, some analytics firms employ manual data collection techniques, such as monitoring curated lists of channels or analyzing user-generated content to identify emerging trends and high-growth channels. While manual methods are labor-intensive, they can provide valuable insights that automated approaches might miss. For instance, identifying channels experiencing rapid subscriber growth due to viral content or successful marketing campaigns can help refine the overall estimate. Combining these varied data collection methods often yields the most robust and accurate estimates, mitigating the weaknesses inherent in any single approach. The accuracy of “how many youtube channels have 1 million subscribers” is therefore inherently dependent on how these third party sources collect their data.
In conclusion, the reliability of any estimate regarding the number of YouTube channels exceeding one million subscribers is inextricably linked to the efficacy and comprehensiveness of the underlying data collection methods. The challenges associated with web scraping, API limitations, and the potential for bias underscore the importance of employing a multi-faceted approach. Continuous refinement of these methods, coupled with increased transparency from YouTube regarding channel metrics, would significantly improve the accuracy and utility of such estimates. Ultimately, a deeper understanding of these data collection techniques is crucial for interpreting and evaluating the available information about the scale and evolution of YouTube’s content landscape.
3. Channel growth rates
Channel growth rates are inextricably linked to the overall count of YouTube channels possessing one million subscribers. The pace at which channels accumulate subscribers directly influences the dynamics of this metric, serving as a key indicator of platform trends and the potential for content creators to achieve widespread reach.
-
Organic Subscriber Acquisition
Organic subscriber acquisition, driven by high-quality content and audience engagement, plays a pivotal role in channel growth rates. Channels producing content that resonates deeply with viewers experience accelerated subscriber growth, contributing to the pool of channels exceeding one million subscribers. For instance, educational channels offering valuable skills or entertainment channels consistently delivering engaging content often see rapid and sustained growth. The absence of organic growth mechanisms necessitates reliance on paid promotion or manipulative tactics, which can yield short-term gains but often fail to establish a loyal subscriber base.
-
Algorithmic Influence
YouTube’s algorithm exerts a significant influence on channel growth rates. Channels whose content aligns with the algorithm’s preferences, based on factors such as watch time, click-through rates, and audience retention, are more likely to be promoted to a wider audience. This algorithmic amplification can lead to exponential subscriber growth, rapidly propelling channels toward the one million subscriber mark. Conversely, channels penalized by the algorithm due to policy violations or declining performance may experience stagnant or negative growth, hindering their ability to reach this threshold. Changes to the algorithm can therefore dramatically alter the landscape, favoring some content categories while disfavoring others.
-
Content Category Dynamics
The content category in which a channel operates significantly impacts its potential growth rate. Certain categories, such as gaming, vlogging, and music, tend to attract larger audiences and experience faster growth due to inherent popularity and broader appeal. Channels in niche or less popular categories may face greater challenges in achieving rapid subscriber growth, even with high-quality content. The competitive landscape within each category also plays a role, with channels competing for viewer attention and subscriber loyalty. Differentiating content and targeting specific sub-niches can be crucial for accelerating growth within competitive categories.
-
External Promotion and Collaboration
External promotion and collaboration can significantly boost channel growth rates. Channels that actively promote their content on other platforms, such as social media or websites, can drive new viewers and subscribers to their YouTube channel. Collaborations with other creators can expose a channel to a wider audience, leveraging the existing subscriber base of the collaborating partner. Strategic partnerships with brands or organizations can also generate valuable exposure and subscriber growth. However, the effectiveness of external promotion and collaboration depends on targeting the right audience and aligning the promotion with the channel’s overall brand and content strategy.
In summation, channel growth rates are a dynamic factor contributing directly to the number of YouTube channels surpassing the one million subscriber benchmark. Organic acquisition, algorithmic promotion, content category trends, and strategic external outreach, all combine to determine the pace at which channels scale. Understanding these factors is crucial for both analyzing the platform’s ecosystem and developing effective growth strategies for aspiring content creators.
4. Subscriber threshold significance
The number of YouTube channels exceeding one million subscribers is directly influenced by the significance attached to this particular threshold. Reaching one million subscribers represents a notable achievement for content creators, often marking a transition from amateur or hobbyist pursuits to a more professional and potentially sustainable endeavor. This milestone typically signifies a channel’s capacity to attract a substantial and engaged audience, creating opportunities for enhanced monetization and expanded brand influence. The perceived value of this subscriber count drives many content creators to invest significant resources, both time and capital, into strategies designed to achieve this benchmark. Thus, the collective efforts to reach this goal subsequently affect the aggregate count of channels surpassing the threshold. Real-life examples abound. Channels focusing on gaming, such as PewDiePie, achieved and surpassed this milestone, demonstrating the potential for broad appeal and substantial revenue generation. Similarly, educational channels, like Khan Academy, demonstrate the power of focused content to attract a large subscriber base. The perceived value, therefore, drives the behavior leading to an increase in the total number.
Furthermore, the one million subscriber mark often serves as a signal to brands and advertisers, indicating a channel’s potential as a valuable marketing partner. Sponsorships, product placements, and other forms of advertising partnerships become more readily available to channels exceeding this threshold, providing additional incentives for content creators to pursue subscriber growth aggressively. The relationship becomes self-reinforcing: as more channels reach one million subscribers and demonstrate their marketing potential, the attractiveness of this milestone increases, further driving the pursuit of subscriber acquisition. However, it is also important to consider the potential for artificial inflation of subscriber counts through the use of bots or other unethical practices. While these methods may temporarily boost a channel’s subscriber count, they do not represent genuine audience engagement and can ultimately undermine the channel’s credibility and long-term sustainability. Despite these concerns, the genuine importance of the million-subscriber threshold, which is the central component in the number of channels that have reached that threshold, remains significant.
In summary, the perceived significance of reaching one million YouTube subscribers acts as a catalyst for content creation efforts, ultimately influencing the aggregate number of channels achieving this feat. This significance stems from the potential for increased monetization, enhanced brand visibility, and recognition within the YouTube ecosystem. While unethical practices may exist, the true value of organically reaching this milestone remains a primary driver for many content creators. Therefore, understanding the incentives behind subscriber growth is essential for comprehending the evolving dynamics of the YouTube platform and the overall distribution of its channels by subscriber count.
5. Monetization potential
Monetization potential serves as a primary motivator for content creators and a significant factor influencing the number of YouTube channels reaching the one million subscriber threshold. The ability to generate revenue from content creation activities incentivizes investment in channel growth, driving the pursuit of higher subscriber counts.
-
Advertising Revenue
Advertising revenue, primarily generated through YouTube’s Partner Program (YPP), constitutes a significant source of income for channels with substantial subscriber bases. Channels meeting eligibility requirements, including exceeding 1,000 subscribers and 4,000 valid watch hours in the past 12 months, can monetize their videos with display, overlay, and video ads. The revenue generated is typically calculated based on cost per mille (CPM) or cost per click (CPC) rates, which fluctuate depending on factors such as ad quality, viewer demographics, and content category. A channel with one million subscribers generally commands higher CPM rates due to its wider reach and potential for attracting a larger audience for advertisers. For example, a channel focusing on finance with a million subscribers is more likely to attract higher CPM’s.
-
Channel Memberships
Channel memberships offer a recurring revenue stream, allowing viewers to support creators directly in exchange for exclusive perks and content. These perks may include custom badges, exclusive emotes, members-only live streams, and early access to videos. The price of memberships is set by the creator, offering flexibility in tailoring the offering to their audience. Channels with a loyal subscriber base are more likely to generate significant revenue through memberships, incentivizing creators to foster strong community engagement. Smaller channels or channels that haven’t reached the million subscriber count face a challenges to convert members.
-
Merchandise Sales
Merchandise sales provide an avenue for channels to generate revenue by selling branded products, such as apparel, accessories, and physical media. Channels with a strong brand identity and a dedicated subscriber base can leverage their popularity to create and sell merchandise that resonates with their audience. The profit margins on merchandise sales can be substantial, offering a significant revenue boost for channels with successful product lines. Furthermore, merchandise sales strengthen brand loyalty and create a tangible connection between creators and their fans. Channels are able to collaborate with different suppliers and brands to achieve the sales objectives.
-
Sponsorships and Brand Deals
Sponsorships and brand deals represent a lucrative monetization opportunity for channels with a sizable and engaged audience. Brands are willing to pay creators to promote their products or services in videos, providing a direct marketing channel to reach a specific target audience. The value of sponsorships and brand deals depends on factors such as the channel’s subscriber count, audience demographics, engagement rates, and content relevance to the brand. Channels with one million subscribers are generally more attractive to brands, commanding higher fees for sponsored content. Furthermore, successful sponsorships can lead to long-term partnerships, creating a sustainable revenue stream for creators.
In conclusion, monetization potential serves as a powerful incentive for content creators to invest in subscriber growth, thereby impacting the number of YouTube channels reaching the one million subscriber milestone. The various monetization methods, including advertising revenue, channel memberships, merchandise sales, and sponsorships, offer diverse opportunities for revenue generation, driving the pursuit of higher subscriber counts and further professionalizing the YouTube ecosystem. The availability and attractiveness of these monetization options significantly contribute to the overall distribution of YouTube channels by subscriber count.
6. Content category distribution
The distribution of content categories on YouTube exhibits a direct correlation with the prevalence of channels exceeding one million subscribers. Certain categories, characterized by broad audience appeal and high engagement levels, tend to foster faster subscriber growth, consequently resulting in a higher concentration of channels reaching this milestone within those specific niches. For instance, entertainment-focused categories, such as music, gaming, and comedy, often showcase a significant number of channels surpassing one million subscribers due to their inherent capacity to attract a diverse and sizable audience. Conversely, more specialized or niche categories may exhibit a comparatively lower proportion of channels attaining this subscriber count, reflecting the limitations of a smaller potential audience base, despite the quality or depth of content offered. Therefore, the uneven distribution of content categories directly influences the overall landscape of channels achieving widespread popularity. A channel focusing on theoretical physics, while possessing valuable educational content, will likely encounter a more constrained audience and slower subscriber growth compared to a channel reviewing popular video games. Thus, category choice presents a fundamental factor in the likelihood of reaching a million subscribers.
Analyzing the content category distribution reveals valuable insights into audience preferences and emerging trends on the platform. Observing which categories are experiencing the most rapid growth in the number of channels surpassing one million subscribers can inform strategic decisions for both aspiring content creators and established media companies. Furthermore, understanding the competitive dynamics within each category is crucial for developing effective content and marketing strategies. The prevalence of channels with large subscriber bases in certain categories may signal increased competition, necessitating a focus on differentiation and innovation to stand out from the crowd. Consider the beauty and fashion category, saturated with content, where successful channels often differentiate themselves through unique presentation styles, specialized tutorials, or a focus on specific demographic niches. This distribution information aids in strategically targeting resources and tailoring content to meet audience demand, optimizing growth potential. The significance of “Content category distribution” as a component of “how many youtube channels have 1 million subscribers” cannot be overstated.
In summation, the relationship between content category distribution and the prevalence of channels exceeding one million subscribers underscores the importance of strategic content planning and audience targeting. While inherent limitations in niche categories exist, understanding these dynamics allows for informed decision-making, optimizing content creation and promotion efforts. A critical challenge remains in adapting to the ever-evolving landscape of audience preferences and platform algorithms. Continuous monitoring of content category trends and a willingness to innovate are paramount for sustaining growth and achieving significant subscriber milestones. The insights gained from analyzing content category distribution provide a valuable lens through which to view the broader trends shaping the YouTube ecosystem.
7. Geographic distribution
The geographic distribution of YouTube channels attaining one million subscribers is intrinsically linked to factors such as internet penetration rates, language demographics, and cultural preferences. Regions with high internet access and large populations speaking dominant languages tend to exhibit a greater concentration of channels exceeding this subscriber threshold. This correlation arises from the expanded potential audience reach afforded by broader internet access and linguistic accessibility. The influence of cultural relevance cannot be overlooked. Content resonant within a specific geographic region may experience accelerated subscriber growth within that area, but might not achieve similar traction in other locales. For instance, channels producing content tailored to the Indian market, with its vast population and diverse linguistic landscape, may accumulate a substantial subscriber base within India and the diaspora, contributing to the overall count of channels with over one million subscribers.
Analyzing the geographic distribution of these channels reveals patterns of content consumption and the varying levels of creator development across different regions. Countries with established media industries and a thriving creator ecosystem often display a higher density of channels exceeding the one million subscriber mark. This suggests that the presence of supportive infrastructure, including access to production resources, marketing expertise, and monetization opportunities, plays a crucial role in fostering channel growth. Conversely, regions with limited internet access, language barriers, or restrictive media policies may exhibit a lower proportion of channels reaching this milestone, despite the potential talent and creativity of content creators in those areas. Such disparities highlight the digital divide and the challenges faced by creators in under-resourced regions. Practical application of this knowledge lies in informing strategies for platform expansion, content localization, and investment in creator development programs in underserved regions.
In summary, the geographic distribution of YouTube channels with over one million subscribers reflects the interplay of factors ranging from internet access to cultural resonance. Understanding these patterns is essential for comprehending the global reach and impact of YouTube, as well as identifying opportunities to address inequalities in access and opportunity. The challenges involved in overcoming these disparities underscore the need for targeted interventions to support creator development and promote content diversity across different geographic regions. This awareness also highlights the importance of “Geographic distribution” as an integral component of “how many youtube channels have 1 million subscribers,” offering crucial insight into the platform’s global ecosystem.
8. Platform policy impact
Platform policies wield considerable influence over channel growth and, consequently, the number of YouTube channels exceeding one million subscribers. Content guidelines, monetization criteria, and algorithmic adjustments instituted by YouTube directly affect a channel’s visibility, revenue potential, and overall ability to attract and retain subscribers. Stringent content policies regarding copyright infringement, hate speech, or misinformation can lead to demonetization or channel termination, hindering growth and reducing the overall count of successful channels. The ever-evolving nature of these policies requires content creators to adapt continuously, investing resources in content moderation and adherence to guidelines to avoid penalties. For instance, changes to YouTube’s advertising policies in 2017, often referred to as the “Adpocalypse,” significantly impacted monetization for numerous channels, particularly those focusing on controversial or sensitive topics, leading to a decline in revenue and, in some cases, subscriber attrition. This policy revision demonstrably altered the trajectory of many channels, highlighting the power of platform policy to shape the landscape of successful content creators.
Algorithmic changes implemented by YouTube also play a crucial role. The algorithm determines which videos are recommended to viewers, influencing traffic and subscriber acquisition. Policies prioritizing watch time, engagement metrics, or specific content formats can disproportionately benefit certain types of channels while disadvantaging others. Channels adapting their content strategies to align with algorithmic preferences often experience accelerated growth, while those failing to do so may struggle to gain traction. The shift towards prioritizing long-form content, for instance, has incentivized channels to produce longer videos, altering content creation practices and potentially impacting subscriber growth for channels traditionally focusing on shorter formats. The “Platform policy impact” is a major point in assessing the number of YouTube channels with 1 million subscribers. The number of channels that reaches a million subscribes is depended on these platform policies. Understanding these algorithmic shifts and adapting to them is therefore paramount for long-term success.
In summary, platform policies exert a profound influence on the YouTube ecosystem and the ability of channels to reach significant subscriber milestones. Content guidelines, monetization criteria, and algorithmic adjustments all contribute to shaping the landscape of successful channels. The constant evolution of these policies necessitates adaptability and strategic content planning from creators, highlighting the critical role of platform policy awareness in navigating the complexities of YouTube and achieving sustained growth. This interplay underscores the importance of policy understanding for all stakeholders aiming to thrive on the platform.
Frequently Asked Questions
This section addresses commonly asked questions concerning the quantity of YouTube channels possessing one million or more subscribers, providing clarity on estimation methodologies and related factors.
Question 1: What is the estimated number of YouTube channels exceeding one million subscribers?
Due to the absence of publicly available data from YouTube, the exact figure remains elusive. Estimates, derived from third-party analytics firms, suggest tens of thousands of channels have surpassed this milestone, although the precise number fluctuates constantly.
Question 2: Why is the exact number of channels not publicly available?
YouTube does not disclose comprehensive aggregate data on channel subscriber counts. The reasons for this lack of transparency are not explicitly stated but likely relate to competitive considerations, data privacy concerns, and the potential for misinterpretation or misuse of the data.
Question 3: How do analytics firms estimate the number of channels with over one million subscribers?
Analytics firms employ a variety of techniques, including web scraping, API access, and statistical modeling, to gather and analyze data on channel subscriber counts. These methods provide an approximate figure, subject to inherent limitations and potential inaccuracies.
Question 4: What factors contribute to the variation in estimates provided by different analytics firms?
Discrepancies in estimates arise from differences in data collection methodologies, analytical algorithms, and the scope of channels monitored by each firm. These variations highlight the challenges associated with estimating a precise number in the absence of official data.
Question 5: What significance does the one million subscriber milestone hold for YouTube channels?
Reaching one million subscribers signifies substantial audience reach, increased brand visibility, and expanded opportunities for monetization through advertising, sponsorships, and merchandise sales. It often marks a channel’s transition to a more professional and sustainable enterprise.
Question 6: How do YouTube’s policies impact the number of channels reaching this subscriber level?
YouTube’s content guidelines, monetization criteria, and algorithmic adjustments directly influence channel growth and revenue potential. Policies restricting content, demonetizing channels, or altering algorithmic recommendations can affect a channel’s ability to attract and retain subscribers, thereby influencing the aggregate count of channels surpassing one million subscribers.
The aggregate of YouTube channels with significant subscriber base represents a dynamic measure influenced by various factors. The accuracy of that measurement has limits due to lack of public information, a reality necessitating awareness of those limitations.
The discussion now shifts to strategies for channels aiming to achieve substantial subscriber growth and navigating the dynamic landscape of online video content creation.
Strategies for Subscriber Growth
Aspiring content creators often seek guidance on effectively increasing their subscriber base and, ideally, joining the ranks of channels exceeding one million subscribers. The following provides a set of actionable strategies for fostering channel growth, emphasizing sustainable practices over short-term gains.
Tip 1: Define a Niche and Target Audience:
Clearly defining a niche and identifying a specific target audience is paramount. Content should resonate strongly with a particular demographic, addressing their interests and needs. A channel dedicated to vintage synthesizer restoration, for example, targets a niche audience passionate about vintage audio equipment, fostering a highly engaged community.
Tip 2: Produce High-Quality, Consistent Content:
Content quality and consistency are fundamental. Regularly publishing well-produced, informative, or entertaining videos cultivates audience expectations and fosters subscriber loyalty. A weekly upload schedule, coupled with consistently high production values, establishes a reliable stream of engaging content.
Tip 3: Optimize Video Titles, Descriptions, and Tags:
Search engine optimization (SEO) is essential for discoverability. Crafting compelling titles, detailed descriptions, and relevant tags enhances video visibility in search results. Keyword research tools can aid in identifying terms that align with the target audience’s search queries.
Tip 4: Engage with the Audience:
Active engagement with viewers cultivates a sense of community. Responding to comments, soliciting feedback, and incorporating viewer suggestions strengthens audience connection. Regularly hosting Q&A sessions or creating content based on viewer requests fosters a more engaged and loyal subscriber base.
Tip 5: Promote Content Across Multiple Platforms:
Expanding reach beyond YouTube involves promoting content across other social media platforms and websites. Sharing videos on relevant forums, engaging on Twitter, and utilizing Instagram stories can drive traffic and increase subscriber acquisition. Cross-promotion strategies leverage existing audiences on other platforms to grow the YouTube subscriber base.
Tip 6: Collaborate with Other Creators:
Collaborations expose channels to new audiences. Partnering with other creators in similar niches expands reach and fosters cross-pollination of subscribers. Jointly creating videos or featuring each other’s content introduces channels to new viewers who share similar interests.
These strategies, consistently implemented, foster sustainable channel growth. Focusing on building a loyal and engaged subscriber base, rather than solely pursuing subscriber counts, provides a more enduring path toward achieving significant milestones.
Attention now turns to the ethical considerations involved in growing a YouTube channel and maintaining a responsible presence on the platform.
Conclusion
The exploration of “how many youtube channels have 1 million subscribers” reveals a complex and dynamic landscape. While a precise figure remains elusive due to the platform’s data policies, estimations suggest that tens of thousands of channels have achieved this milestone. This achievement signifies substantial reach, potential monetization, and influence within the online video ecosystem. Factors influencing this number include algorithmic shifts, content category popularity, geographic distribution, and the ever-evolving platform policies that shape content creation and audience engagement.
Understanding the factors contributing to the number of YouTube channels exceeding this benchmark provides valuable insight into the evolving dynamics of the platform. Aspiring creators and industry analysts should continue to monitor these trends to navigate the competitive landscape and capitalize on emerging opportunities. Further investigation into the long-term impact of achieving this subscriber level on channel sustainability and influence warrants future exploration.
